GOSPEL WIKI

Gospel Wiki› Book of Mormon› the three

The Three Who Tarry

Three of the twelve Nephite disciples ask — without daring to speak it — for what the record says John the Beloved asked: to remain on the earth and bring souls to Christ until his coming. It is granted. They are caught up into heaven, set apart by a change wrought upon their bodies, and thereafter cannot be held: prison, pit, furnace, and den of beasts all release them. Mormon, editing the account, cannot at first tell whether they are mortal or immortal — writes “I know not” — and then, between drafts, receives the revelation that settles it.

Account

The question, and the desire they dared not speak

After the risen Lord finishes speaking, he turns to the twelve he has chosen and asks each, “one by one,” what he desires “after that I am gone to the Father” (3 Nephi 28:1). Nine answer that they wish, after a full life, to “speedily come unto thee in thy kingdom” (3 Nephi 28:2); the grant is exact — at “seventy and two years old ye shall come unto me in my kingdom” (3 Nephi 28:3). Then he turns to the remaining three (3 Nephi 28:4). They cannot say what they want: “they sorrowed in their hearts, for they durst not speak unto him the thing which they desired” (3 Nephi 28:5). He answers the unspoken wish and names its precedent — “ye have desired the thing which John, my beloved” desired of him (3 Nephi 28:6). The record supplies its own comparison here: the three’s desire is the desire of John, a figure the text names but whose story belongs to another scripture. The wiki reports the comparison as the text makes it and does not reach outside the account to develop John.

Never to taste of death: the promise, and the two changes

The grant is stated in escalating clauses. They “shall never taste of death”; instead they “shall live to behold all the doings of the Father unto the children of men, even until all things shall be fulfilled according to the will of the Father, when I shall come in my glory with the powers of heaven” (3 Nephi 28:7). They “shall never endure the pains of death; but when I shall come in my glory ye shall be changed in the twinkling of an eye from mortality to immortality” (3 Nephi 28:8). And in the meantime they “shall not have pain while ye shall dwell in the flesh, neither sorrow save it be for the sins of the world” (3 Nephi 28:9). The stated reason is the desire itself: “ye have desired that ye might bring the souls of men unto me, while the world shall stand” (3 Nephi 28:9).

The phrase “changed in the twinkling of an eye from mortality to immortality” (3 Nephi 28:8) has no earlier occurrence anywhere in this record — a search of the record finds “twinkling” and the “mortality to immortality” pairing only in this chapter (here and at 28:36). Its well-known parallel (1 Corinthians 15:52, a frozen corpus text) is noted only as a reader may recognize it, not registered as a connection. Whether the phrase recurs in the record’s later books is left to those books.

The account is careful to distinguish this last-day change from the change the three actually receive now. After the revelation reported below, Mormon states that the interim “change wrought upon their bodies, that they might not suffer pain nor sorrow save it were for the sins of the world” (3 Nephi 28:38) — the same “sorrow save… for the sins of the world” clause already promised at 28:9 — “was not equal to that which shall take place at the last day” (3 Nephi 28:39). Its effect was that “Satan could have no power over them, that he could not tempt them; and they were sanctified in the flesh” (3 Nephi 28:39); and “in this state they were to remain until the judgment day of Christ; and at that day they were to receive a greater change” (3 Nephi 28:40). Two changes, an interim one and a greater one — the distinction is the text’s own, not an inference laid over it.

The transfiguration Mormon could not resolve

The clearest thing about chapter 28 is not the miracle but the seam it leaves in the record. When the Lord touches the nine and departs, the three are “caught up into heaven, and saw and heard unspeakable things” (3 Nephi 28:13), which “it was forbidden them that they should utter” (3 Nephi 28:14). The uncertainty begins with the three themselves: “whether they were in the body or out of the body, they could not tell; for it did seem unto them like a transfiguration of them, that they were changed from this body of flesh into an immortal state” (3 Nephi 28:15).

Mormon then states his own limit, in the record’s own voice about the record’s own subject: “whether they were mortal or immortal, from the day of their transfiguration, I know not” (3 Nephi 28:17) — and immediately bounds the admission with what the account does establish: “But this much I know, according to the record which hath been given—they did go forth upon the face of the land, and did minister unto all the people” (3 Nephi 28:18).

He then marks a break in his own editing: “I, Mormon, make an end of speaking concerning these things for a time” (3 Nephi 28:24). When he resumes, he reports that the interval carried an answer. Of “those whom the Lord hath chosen, yea, even three who were caught up into the heavens,” he had “knew not whether they were cleansed from mortality to immortality” (3 Nephi 28:36); “But behold, since I wrote, I have inquired of the Lord, and he hath made it manifest unto me that there must needs be a change wrought upon their bodies, or else it needs be that they must taste of death” (3 Nephi 28:37). The resolution (28:38–40) then follows.

This whole sequence — a stated uncertainty, a paused draft, a revelation received in the interval, and the answer folded back into the same chapter — is a fact about how the record was composed, and it is reported here as textual fact rather than as an interpretation to be weighed. It is treated at greater length on Narrative Voice; Mormon’s uncertainty and his later answer are the text’s own words.

The persecutions that cannot hold them

The three’s ministry after the visitation is narrated as a catalog of deliverances. They gather and baptize converts (3 Nephi 28:18); then the account records that no confinement holds them.

[Textual] — shared phrasing. A prison “rent in twain” to free imprisoned servants of God occurs in this record at two places — the deliverance of Alma and Amulek at Ammonihah, and the deliverance of the three:

  • 3 Nephi 28:19: “the prisons could not hold them, for they were rent in twain”
  • Alma 14:27: “the walls of the prison were rent in twain, so that they fell to the earth”

The bare phrase “rent in twain” is common in the record — it describes rocks broken in the destruction (3 Nephi 8:18; Helaman 14:22) and a temple in a conditional (Helaman 10:8). What these verses share is its application to a prison, which occurs at three loci — these two and 4 Nephi 1:30, where the same three disciples’ prisons “were rent in twain” again. The intervening generation of the same kind of miracle — imprisoned preachers delivered by the power of God — is Nephi and Lehi at Helaman 5:21–44; but there the prison walls “did shake as if they were about to tumble to the earth; but behold, they did not fall” (Helaman 5:27) — a trembling, not a rending. So the rending proper is a three-point set (Alma and Amulek → the three → the three again in 4 Nephi), while the broader pattern of miraculous prison-deliverance runs four generations.

The catalog continues past the prison. Cast into the earth, “they did smite the earth with the word of God, insomuch that by his power they were delivered out of the depths of the earth” (3 Nephi 28:20). “Thrice they were cast into a furnace and received no harm” (3 Nephi 28:21); “twice were they cast into a den of wild beasts; and behold they did play with the beasts as a child with a suckling lamb, and received no harm” (3 Nephi 28:22). The furnace and the den of beasts have familiar parallels in the book of Daniel (Daniel 3; Daniel 6), frozen corpus text since the Old-Testament freeze; they are reported here as the account gives them and are not developed or registered.

Names withheld, and Mormon’s own witness

Mormon nearly records who the three are, and is stopped: “I was about to write the names of those who were never to taste of death, but the Lord forbade; therefore I write them not, for they are hid from the world” (3 Nephi 28:25). The withholding is one instance of the record’s stated policy of writing only a “lesser part” until permitted more — treated on Coming Forth of Scripture — and is noted here, not re-hosted. Against the concealment stands Mormon’s personal claim: “I have seen them, and they have ministered unto me” (3 Nephi 28:26).

The charter: among all nations, and unknown

The three are given a scope that reaches past the Nephites entirely. They “will be among the Gentiles, and the Gentiles shall know them not” (3 Nephi 28:27); “They will also be among the Jews, and the Jews shall know them not” (3 Nephi 28:28). When the Lord sees fit, they “shall minister unto all the scattered tribes of Israel, and unto all nations, kindreds, tongues and people, and shall bring out of them unto Jesus many souls” (3 Nephi 28:29). Their state is put in one figure: “they are as the angels of God, and if they shall pray unto the Father in the name of Jesus they can show themselves unto whatsoever man it seemeth them good” (3 Nephi 28:30). And their work is aimed at a fixed horizon — “great and marvelous works shall be wrought by them, before the great and coming day when all people must surely stand before the judgment-seat of Christ” (3 Nephi 28:31); “among the Gentiles shall there be a great and marvelous work wrought by them, before that judgment day” (3 Nephi 28:32).

By its own words, then, the account of the three does not end in this book: they are to “behold all the doings of the Father… even until all things shall be fulfilled” (3 Nephi 28:7) and to “remain until the judgment day of Christ” (3 Nephi 28:40), ministering through the record’s later books. That the text declares this forward arc is a fact about chapter 28; the arc’s later text is now frozen in corpus (4 Nephi 1:14, 1:30–33, 1:37; the last sighting at Mormon 8:10–11), and it is taken up in the sections that follow.

The arc, enacted: the three in the later books

The chapter’s declared future is carried out in the record’s later books. The converted society of 4 Nephi holds for nearly two centuries with the three among the people; as it decays, the same deliverances chapter 28 first recorded are recorded again of the same three; and four hundred years after Christ they are seen a last time, still ministering.

Still tarrying, a hundred years on

At the hundred-year mark the record accounts for the chosen disciples and singles out the three: they “had all gone to the paradise of God, save it were the three who should tarry; and there were other disciples ordained in their stead” (4 Nephi 1:14). The designation is the chapter’s own — the same three, named again as “the three disciples of Jesus who should tarry” (4 Nephi 1:37), whom chapter 28 called “the three who were to tarry” (3 Nephi 28:12) — so the three’s identity across the books is a textual fact, not an inference.

⚖️ Interpretation — weigh this. Read together, 4 Nephi 1:14 shows the promise of 3 Nephi 28:7 holding: the nine who asked to “speedily come” to Christ (3 Nephi 28:2) have “gone to the paradise of God,” while the three, told they should “never taste of death” (3 Nephi 28:7), alone remain. The identity of the three is textual (the shared designation above); what is offered to weigh is only the reading of 1:14 as the specific enactment of the 28:7 promise — the two verses hold the same three and the same fact but no distinctive phrase in common, so the link is set out for the reader rather than asserted as the text’s own cross-reference.

The deliverances, recorded again

When the society has divided and a church “which denied the Christ” (4 Nephi 1:29) rises against “the disciples of Jesus who did tarry with them” (4 Nephi 1:30) — the three — the persecutions run in the same order, and nearly the same words, as the catalog of chapter 28. The record supplies its own comparison for the intent behind them: the people “did seek to kill them, even as the Jews at Jerusalem sought to kill Jesus, according to his word” (4 Nephi 1:31). That likeness is the text’s own, made inside the account; the wiki reports it as the record states it and does not reach outside for a parallel.

[Textual] — shared phrasing. The three deliverances of 4 Nephi 1:30–33 match, one for one, the catalog first given at 3 Nephi 28:19–22:

  • Prison — 4 Nephi 1:30: “the prisons were rent in twain” · 3 Nephi 28:19: “the prisons could not hold them, for they were rent in twain”. (Of a prison, “rent in twain” occurs at three loci — Alma 14:27, 3 Nephi 28:19, 4 Nephi 1:30; the 28:19 / Alma 14:27 leg and its four-generation chain are treated above under )
  • Furnace — 4 Nephi 1:32: “they did cast them into furnaces of fire, and they came forth receiving no harm” · 3 Nephi 28:21: “thrice they were cast into a furnace and received no harm”.
  • Beasts — 4 Nephi 1:33: “they did play with the wild beasts even as a child with a lamb” · 3 Nephi 28:22: “they did play with the beasts as a child with a suckling lamb”.

The two records differ in small, reportable ways — given here as textual facts and not read for significance: 4 Nephi has “furnaces of fire” (plural) where chapter 28 has “a furnace”; “dens of wild beasts” (plural) where 28 has “a den”; and “a child with a lamb” where 28 has “a child with a suckling lamb”.

The one sorrow they were allowed

The single exception written into the promise surfaces as the society falls. The three had been told they should feel no “sorrow save it be for the sins of the world” (3 Nephi 28:9), the one grief left them; and when pride, riches, and the rebuilt Gadianton oaths have taken the people (4 Nephi 1:42–43), the record turns to the three: “And from this time the disciples began to sorrow for the sins of the world” (4 Nephi 1:44).

[Textual] — shared phrasing. The collocation “sorrow … for the sins of the world” occurs at exactly three loci in this record, all of them about the three:

  • 4 Nephi 1:44: “the disciples began to sorrow for the sins of the world”
  • 3 Nephi 28:9: “neither sorrow save it be for the sins of the world”
  • 3 Nephi 28:38: “that they might not suffer pain nor sorrow save it were for the sins of the world”

The single grief the promise had allowed is the one the decay finally brings. (The phrase “sins of the world” is common in the record, but everywhere else it is Christ who takes away the sins of the world; the sorrow-collocation is confined to these three verses. The contiguous shared string is “for the sins of the world” — in 28:9 the words “save it be” interrupt — so this is distinctive shared phrasing, not a whole-clause verbatim match.)

Withdrawn from the people, and seen a last time

The three’s presence among the Nephites ends in Mormon’s childhood: “wickedness did prevail upon the face of the whole land, insomuch that the Lord did take away his beloved disciples, and the work of miracles and of healing did cease” (Mormon 1:13); Mormon, forbidden to preach, records that “the beloved disciples were taken away out of the land, because of their iniquity” (Mormon 1:16). Moroni later names who these were and why they went: “there are none that do know the true God save it be the disciples of Jesus, who did tarry in the land until the wickedness of the people was so great that the Lord would not suffer them to remain with the people; and whether they be upon the face of the land no man knoweth” (Mormon 8:10). The tarrying disciples are the three; their withdrawal, not their death, is what the record reports.

⚖️ Interpretation — weigh this. Against that withdrawal stands the corpus’s last sighting of them. Four hundred years after Christ (Mormon 8:6), Moroni writes: “But behold, my father and I have seen them, and they have ministered unto us” (Mormon 8:11). This is the record’s final word on the three, and it reads as the keeping of the promise made at the first — that they should “live to behold all the doings of the Father unto the children of men, even until all things shall be fulfilled” (3 Nephi 28:7). (Mormon’s own earlier witness of them is at 3 Nephi 28:26.) The pairing to the promise is offered to weigh because it rests on the shared identity of the three and the promise, not on a phrase the two verses hold in common.

Named a last time, in Moroni’s faith-index (Ether 12:17)

Beyond the last sighting the record continues into the frozen book of Ether. The three do not appear in its narrative — they postdate the Jaredite record entirely — but Moroni, closing Ether with a litany of faith-heroes (Ether 12:13–22), names them once, indexing their promise as one instance of the faith by which “all they who wrought miracles wrought them by faith” (Ether 12:16):

[Textual] — shared phrasing. Moroni’s register-index of the three’s grant, restating the promise by its own signature phrase:

  • Ether 12:17: “it was by faith that the three disciples obtained a promise that they should not taste of death; and they obtained not the promise until after their faith.”
  • 3 Nephi 28:7: “ye shall never taste of death; but ye shall live to behold all the doings of the Father unto the children of men, even until all things shall be fulfilled”.

The shared string is “taste of death,” a phrase confined in the record to the three — five verses, all of this account: 3 Nephi 28:7, 28:25, 28:37, 28:38, and Moroni’s index here. Moroni traces the grant, as the risen Lord did (28:6), to faith rather than to any merit of the men — the promise “obtained not… until after their faith.” (Ether’s two other references to “disciples” are not the three: “my disciples” at Ether 4:10 and “thy disciples” at Ether 12:31 name the Lord’s disciples generally and the twelve to whom he showed himself in power. The three are named in Ether only at 12:17.)

So the book of Ether resolves the question narrowly: it adds no story of the three, only Moroni’s one-line witness that their never-taste-death promise was obtained “by faith.” The book of Moroni is frozen and built (Moroni build, 2026-07-04); it adds no material on the three (verified by search — the three are named in Ether only at 12:17, and the book of Moroni’s disciple-references are the twelve), and nothing from it appears here.

Significance

The three are defined by a single desire and a single condition. The desire is stated plainly — to “bring the souls of men” to Christ “while the world shall stand” (3 Nephi 28:9) — and it is the same desire the record attributes to John the Beloved (28:6). The condition is a change that suspends death without granting the last-day resurrection: an interim change now, “not equal to that which shall take place at the last day” (28:39), and a “greater change” reserved for the judgment day (28:40).

The page’s most distinctive feature is not the miracles but the seam in the record. Mormon’s “I know not” (28:17) and his later “since I wrote, I have inquired of the Lord” (28:37) make chapter 28 the record’s clearest surviving instance of its own text being revised by revelation mid-composition — the reason the chapter belongs as much to Narrative Voice as to the three themselves.

The registered connections fall into two groups. The prison-deliverance places the three at the end of a three-generation pattern of miraculous prison-deliverance — Alma and Amulek, then Nephi and Lehi, then the three — with the specific prison-rent-in-twain wording binding the first generation and the last. The rest hold the chapter’s declared future against the record’s later books: the same three deliverances recorded again in 4 Nephi (prison, furnace, den of beasts), the one permitted sorrow “for the sins of the world” arriving as the converted society falls, and — set out as readings to weigh, not settled cross-references — the continuation of the three at a hundred years and their last sighting four hundred years after Christ. One further leg comes from the frozen book of Ether, where Moroni names the three a last time — indexing their never-taste-death promise (3 Nephi 28:7) among his faith-heroes on the shared phrase “taste of death” (). The reader should keep two disciplines in view. First, several elements here have well-known parallels in frozen corpus texts this page does not treat — the twinkling-of-an-eye change (28:8; compare 1 Corinthians 15:52), the furnace and the den of beasts (28:21–22; compare Daniel 3 and Daniel 6), and John the Beloved’s parallel desire (28:6; compare John 21:22) — and each such parallel is reported as the account gives it, not developed or registered here. (The furnace and the den of beasts also echo within the record, in 4 Nephi; that in-record echo, unlike the cross-corpus parallels, is a registered connection above.) Second, the folk traditions that later attach to “the three” are external, real-world material outside this wiki’s scope; the page maps only the text’s internal account.

Key references

Twelve Disciples · The Visitation at Bountiful · Nephi (Jr.) · Narrative Voice · Nephi Helamanson · Amulek · Alma the Younger · Coming Forth of Scripture · Mormon · Index · Connections

Sources

The Book of Mormon (3 Nephi 28; 4 Nephi 1; Mormon 1 and 8; Ether 12:17 for Moroni’s faith-litany reference to the three; Alma 14:27, Helaman 5:21–44, 5:27, and 4 Nephi 1:30 for the prison-deliverance cross-references; 3 Nephi 8:18, Helaman 10:8, 14:22 for the “rent in twain” phrase distribution).

Every quote on this page is taken verbatim from the source text — 3 Nephi 28; 4 Nephi 1; Mormon 1 and 8; and, for the prison cross-references, Alma 14:27, Helaman 5:21–44 and 5:27, with 3 Nephi 8:18, Helaman 10:8 and 14:22 for the “rent in twain” phrase distribution — each cited to its verse. The [Textual] badges report verbal facts confirmed by search of the record: a prison “rent in twain” occurs at Alma 14:27, 3 Nephi 28:19, and 4 Nephi 1:30; the three deliverances of 3 Nephi 28:19–22 are recorded again at 4 Nephi 1:30–33; and the “sorrow … for the sins of the world” collocation occurs only at 3 Nephi 28:9, 28:38, and 4 Nephi 1:44 (all three-Nephites material). Two ⚖️ interpretive callouts are made — the continuation of the three at a hundred years (4 Nephi 1:14 ↔ 3 Nephi 28:7) and the last sighting four hundred years after Christ (Mormon 8:11 ↔ 3 Nephi 28:7) — each resting on the shared identity of the three plus the promise, not on a shared phrase, and each offered to be weighed rather than asserted. Mormon’s uncertainty about the transfiguration (28:15–17) and its resolution by later revelation (28:36–40) are reported as the record’s own words. Items with a parallel elsewhere in the frozen corpus — the twinkling-of-an-eye change (28:8; 1 Corinthians 15:52), the furnace and the den of beasts (28:21–22; Daniel 3 and 6 — whose in-record echo in 4 Nephi is, by contrast, a registered connection), and John the Beloved’s parallel desire (28:6; John 21:22) — are reported as the account gives them, and those cross-corpus parallels are not developed or registered on this page. Of the record’s books beyond Mormon, Ether is now frozen and folded in above — the three are named there only once, in Moroni’s faith-litany (Ether 12:17, registered as on the shared phrase “taste of death”), with no narrative of them; Moroni remains unfrozen and nothing is anticipated from it on this page. External historicity and folk traditions about the three are out of scope.