GOSPEL WIKI

Gospel Wiki Connections eth-sc-record-transmitted-evil

Ether 8:9 · Alma 37:29

Textual Paraphrase

This connection's citations are checked against the source text.

The badges and the mark are separate signals: Textual and Interpretive name the kind of claim a connection makes, while the mark reports that the connection's citations were checked.

Book of Mormon Ether 8:9
"Hath he not read the record which our fathers brought across the great deep? Behold, is there not an account concerning them of old, that they by their secret plans did obtain kingdoms and great glory?"
Book of Mormon Alma 37:29
"Therefore ye shall keep these secret plans of their oaths and their covenants from this people, and only their wickedness and their murders and their abominations shall ye make known unto them"

The combination is itself record-transmitted evil -- the daughter of Jared revives the oaths not by inventing them but by READING them out of the old account: 'Hath he not read the record which our fathers brought across the great deep? … an account concerning them of old, that they by their secret plans did obtain kingdoms and great glory' (Ether 8:9). That is the precise danger Alma's embargo was laid to forestall: 'ye shall keep these secret plans of their oaths and their covenants from this people' (Alma 37:29) -- the plans withheld, as the embargo verse states, 'lest peradventure they should fall into darkness' (Alma 37:27). The shared phrase is 'secret plans' -- a seven-verse corpus phrase (Alma 37:29, 37:32; Ether 8:9, 9:26, 13:15; Helaman 11:10, 11:26), the recurring lexeme of the whole withheld-oaths thread. Alma 37:29 is chosen over 37:27 (which anchors the embargo record eth-sc-embargo-third) and over 37:21 (the twenty-four-plates verse, but its valence is 'made manifest', the opposite of concealment) because 37:29 shares the exact phrase 'secret plans' and states the embargo's rationale specifically about the plans being read and transmitted. Cross-link hel-sc-buried-plans-inversion (Helaman 11:10 <-> Alma 37:29): where the Nephites bury their own secret plans and Alma sealed the old ones, the daughter of Jared is the archetype of the reader the embargo feared.

Discussed on

Secret Combinations